Takeaways From Delaware County’s 2026 Elections

11.4.2026 / News / Daisy Dale

It was a bloodbath. There is zero ambiguity about what went wrong for Republicans, and hardly a chance of any results from last night being contested as many feared.

Besides Sara Gullion retaining Democratic control of the State Representative District 34 seat, her win with a near two thirds of the vote (63.24%) will continue to be promising. Between 2012 and 2024, Sue Errington had been decreasing her lead over time, as she beat Joe Shank in 2016 with 65.70%, in 2020 beat Dale Basham with 56.4%, then Susan Dillon in 2024 with 55.1%.

Public safety, police and fire, made several endorsements for Democrats including Dave Williams for sheriff and Ken Mace for county commissioner (both of which won handily) and it’s very possible that if the party ran an opponent for prosecutor, Eric Hoffman would have been beat.

This year the Political Action Committee of the Muncie Fire Fighters Local 1348 made no endorsement between Cameron Grubbs and Sharon McShurley for county clerk. McShurley previously was a mayor in Muncie who got rid of four fire stations and fired many people serving during her tenure between 2008 and 2011. According to WTHR, McShurley considered privatizing the fire department along with other egregious incidents. Grubbs has been known to rustle similar feathers but only from memes, and had a reputation over the years on Facebook that perhaps made the Muncie Fire Fighters’ PAC refrain from choosing Grubbs over McShurley. Regardless, Grubbs won last night by 256 votes.

For the loses on the Democratic ticket, major gaps were closed and could remain tight races for more election cycles (both for Cody York who received 49.27% and Michael Durall with 47.80%). Andrew Dale’s race for state senate was between Delaware County and Randolph County, and while receiving a 50.91% here it was Randolph County where he received 35.85%, and a total gap of 1,192 votes. Wider gaps included Phil Gift with 40.62% and John Barlett with 40.73% each within Delaware.

Election turnout went up from 38.86% in 2022 to 42.09% this year, and between Grubbs’ win here and Beau Bayh’s win for Secretary of State, election integrity will be better than ever.

Daisy Dale is the editor and publisher of The Muncie Post-Democrat, a commissioner for the Muncie Human Rights Commission, and a board member of Muncie Queer Alliance.

Scroll to Top