From Waelz Kilns to Data Centers: A Model for Community Action

10.22.2026 / Essay / Brad King

Photo from protest against Waelz Sustainable Products facility. August 5, 2019.

Article from Brad King. Republished with permission.

For those of you that were around Muncie in 2019, you’ll remember hearing about the Waelz Sustainable Products (WSP) metal recycling facility along SR32 on the former BorgWarner property. This facility would have used rotary kilns to process electric arc furnace dust from steel mills to recover zinc-containing material. Although presented as industrial recycling and brownfield redevelopment, the proposed facility emissions of lead, mercury, and particulates became public concern. What followed was a broad, decentralized grassroots opposition that succeeded in stopping a major industrial development, after the city had already approved economic development incentives.

Seven years later, modern large-scale data centers and small modular reactors (SMRs), that use nuclear fission to generate low-carbon electricity, heat, and hydrogen, are threatening Delaware County. Data centers and SMRs offer very different impacts on our air, land, and water than the kiln facility. WSP’s Muncie facility’s permit identified potential emissions of lead, mercury, cadmium, particulate matter, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants. Those pollutants cause concerns about respiratory illness, neurological effects, and of heavy metals being deposited onto surrounding properties from the electric arc kilns. The Waelz facility would have used approximately 30 acres at the former BorgWarner site. The facility could have potentially contaminated the soil further from emissions of airborne deposition, dust, spills, and the storage or handling of metal-bearing materials and kiln residues. There was also concern for potential contamination of surface water and groundwater through stormwater runoff, spills, improper waste handling, and deposited airborne metals washing into waterways. The vast majority of these environmental concerns were toxic pollutants.

SMRs have minimal direct air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during normal operation. They generate noise from cooling and mechanical equipment. Even generally smaller operational footprints still require security buffers and supporting infrastructure, which converts a large area of land from its current use. Depending on reactor designs, water-cooled systems may require substantial withdrawals for cooling, with evaporative losses or heated water discharges affecting aquatic ecosystems. Some SMR designs require much less water. However, with SMRs there is the unique potential for radioactive releases. Instances with radioactive contamination are mostly by accident or a result of containment-failure, rather than routine discharge of untreated radioactive materials. Normal operations can involve limited, regulated radioactive effluents.

A large artificial intelligence (AI, I refuse to call it super intelligence) data center emits nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and greenhouse gases from on-site diesel generators or natural gas turbines. Their cooling equipment creates continuous mechanical noise, with documented acoustic studies projecting levels ranging from approximately 40 to 60 dBA at nearby properties, depending on distance, equipment, and noise mitigation measures. These facilities usually require very large footprints which, depending on placement, can cause the loss of farmland and natural habitats. High-density graphics processing unit (GPU) clusters often require advanced liquid cooling. Although both systems use water for cooling, closed-loop systems recirculate most of their water with relatively little consumption, while evaporative cooling systems consume substantially more water through evaporation and require regular replenishment. Groundwater and river water pollution sources from data centers come from wastewater containing cooling chemicals and concentrated minerals, and any contamination from possible fuel or chemical spills.

Both developments for data centers and SMRs share some environmental risks, but each also presents unique concerns. They could all severely impact the direct environment they are in and place additional demands on local electric and water utilities, even potentially raising costs for customers. These are High-Impact Developments: large-scale development that, due to size, location, operations, resource consumption, emissions, or waste generation, have the potential to create substantial adverse impacts on air, land, water, infrastructure, or surrounding land uses. These projects’ impact on the environment should receive a high level of scrutiny in the review process.

Communities want development, but development should respond to the needs of the community and provide more benefit to the community than adverse impacts. As a community, we don’t have to single out metal recycling centers, or small modular nuclear reactor families, or demand-drive AI data centers. We can judge developments based on their impacts to the environment and their contributions to our community. And while these large-scale developments may seem undefeatable, there is a strong lesson to be learned from the Waelz Kiln opposition.

In January of 2019, the city announced the kiln project as an industrial investment and opportunity to redevelop the former BorgWarner site. By that summer, public concern grew as WSP’s air permit application at Indiana Department of Environmental Management (IDEM) showed potential for hazardous emissions. During that summer, the City Council approved tax incentives for the project. In August 2019, hundreds of people mobilized at Muncie City Hall. Approximately 215 filled the auditorium, dozens remained in the lobby, and more than 400 assembled outside. Council members moved to reconsider the project after a contentious public comment session. That same month following the council meeting, the opposition expanded as the Delaware County Health Department and Yorktown Town Council opposed the proposal. Ball State and IU Health Ball Memorial leadership expressed conditional opposition pending answers on the health risks. On August 20, 2019, the city and developers canceled the project. The property was to be sold back to the Muncie Redevelopment Commission, but that never occurred. Because it was already planned, scheduled, and ready, there was a forum held regarding the project despite the cancellation announcement. Josh Arthur hosted the Waelz Sustainable Products Expert Panelist Forum at Muncie Central High School.

Now there was a lot more to this public victory than 20 days of public pressure and protest. Just like the panel of experts took time to assemble, find a location, set a time and date; learning about this project, its adverse effects, connecting with other like-minded citizens, and organizing took a lot of time and resources as well. While the most dynamic aspects of the movement came in August of that year, the prep work took months and many people. Josh Arthur was pastor of Avondale United Methodist Church and helped organize residents, public information efforts, and the August experts forum. Dave Ring is the owner of The Downtown Farm Stand and helped organize a social media opposition to the facility. Dr. Jim Rybarczyk was a Ball State chemistry professor who examined the permit application and identified numerous technical concerns. Indra Frank was the Hoosier Environmental Council representative who publicly addressed the health risks of mercury and lead emissions. Bryan Preston, a GIS specialist and local advocate, described the opposition as a broad grassroots movement with many independent participants rather than a centrally directed campaign and helped organize public information efforts. There were also many neighborhoods, churches, and civic groups that helped distribute information and mobilize citizens.

(For anyone who I may have not included but perhaps should have, I apologize. The omission is not purposeful.)

What these people did was successfully oppose a project that had already received governmental support. Their methods can be used to form a model for future development protests. If you notice in the description of just some of the folks involved, you’ll notice not one of them was a director or chair or held a formal leadership position within a single oppositional organization. The movement was a decentralized grassroots civic action. That’s not to say those folks and others involved weren’t leaders, but there was no centralized organizing. They were able to blend several approaches that complemented the action. I would describe the steps to these actions as:

Identify: discover the proposal and identify the required process.
Research: gather documentation and independent technical expertise.
Inform: share findings through public forums and accessible communication.
Organize: connect residents, civic groups, experts, and institutions.
Participate: engage decision-makers and participate in formal meetings and hearings.

I would add one more step, because public engagement should not stop at the decision. Developments can be modified, approved with conditions, or reintroduced later.

Continue: maintain public oversight through the decision and subsequent implementation.

The kiln project was a bit different from the possible contemporary project near the International Aeromodeling Center (IAC) owned by the Academy of Model Aeronautics (AMA). WSP was seeking direct public financing assistance in the project. The redevelopment commission was involved in the BorgWarner site transfer. The City Council could effectively halt the process especially by revoking their tax breaks for the project. High-impact developments, like the one rumored at the IAC may not be so directly prevented by pressuring the governing body, in this case the County Commissioners. For one, the AMA is a private non-profit and may sell their land to anyone they so choose pending their own by-laws and applicable laws. As of the writing of this piece, the developers have not sought public subsidies. The biggest opportunity for the public to take civic action in the IAC/AMA situation is at the Board of Zoning Appeals. The land in that area is in four zones: Business Variety, Farming, Recreation and Conservation, and Residential (zone 2).

The Business Variety zoning classification permits a broad range of commercial activities, incorporating uses allowed in the other business zones (i.e. Central Business, Limited Business, and Community Business). Additional permitted uses include: recreational businesses, hotels, equipment sales and rentals, veterinary facilities, welding and plumbing shops, building material storage, and other commercial services. Although this classification allows some light industry activities, it does not expressly allow high-impact industrial facilities. Farming zoning classification permits common agricultural and rural residential uses, including single-family homes, farming, livestock operations, orchards, nurseries, roadside agricultural stands, sawmills, veterinary facilities, and limited agricultural composting, subject to certain standards. Certain institutional and community uses, such as schools, religious institutions, government facilities, and cemeteries, are also permitted. Any allowed commercial and industrial activities are related to farming operations. The Residential zone 2 classification is primarily residential, permitting single-family homes along with government buildings, schools, colleges, universities, and religious institutions. Accessory structures and temporary construction facilities are also allowed. Unlike the farming uses, this district does not generally allow farming operations or commercial and industrial activities. The Recreation and Conservation Zone classification is intended to preserve land for recreational activities and natural resources. Permitted uses include parks, trails, golf courses, athletic fields, swimming pools, recreation lakes, wildlife preserves, and similar facilities. Other compatible commercial recreational uses may be approved conditionally by the Board of Zoning Appeals. Residential development, non-recreational commercial activities, and industrial uses are expressly prohibited.

A high-impact development whose proposed use is not permitted in any of those zones would require a use variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals or a change in zoning. This is true of all property owners who may want to use the land for something other than what is permitted for in its current zone. They can apply to get special permission to perform an otherwise prohibited activity. To do so, the applicant provides the location of the area to scale, proof of ownership, a detailed narrative explaining the deviation and the reason for it, notification to neighborhoods and the general public, then a public hearing to determine the case. Without a use variance or change in zoning, a development involving a prohibited use cannot proceed. This is a critical process for the public to attend. This is when the public can stand up to unwanted development, especially those with substantial adverse environmental impacts.

If we look at the Waelz Kiln opposition movement and adapt its method to this project, the public should be watching for the notices, getting copies of the proposed use, examining the potential effects, informing people, finding institutional partners in opposition, and organizing them to intervene in the public meeting. Leading up to any BZA meeting, the movement could encourage public participation and organize residents to present documented concerns about the project’s impacts, while recognizing that the Board must evaluate the proposal according to the zoning ordinance and applicable legal requirements. Currently, multiple social media groups have emerged in opposition to the potential development at the IAC/AMA site. A decentralized grassroots movement is beginning to take shape, with several individuals assuming organizing roles and public meetings just getting underway. These are some of the same elements that helped make the Waelz Kiln opposition successful.

The Waelz Kiln opposition movement showed that large-scale, high-impact developments can be stopped, even after economic incentives have been approved. Using their model of opposition can help current and future opposition movements against similar developments achieve success. The increased computing demand from cryptocurrency mining and AI is pushing more data centers into development, especially in states like Indiana. Current and prospective County Commissioners have expressed a desire for large-scale data centers. Recently the County Commissioners approved a letter of intent regarding Indiana Advanced Nuclear Ready Communities Program sent to the Indiana Office of Energy Development. So it would seem that SMRs as well as large-scale data centers have attracted the current county administration’s interest.

The other opportunities for the public to intersect the process are permits at the state level, namely IDEM construction stormwater permit, air quality permit, and potentially a wastewater (NPDES) permit. If it requires a significant water withdrawal (>100,000 gallons per day) then they would need a permit from the DNR. Nearly each one of those permit processes allows for a 30-day public input.

The lesson from the Waelz opposition is that communities do not need a single organization or designated leader to participate effectively in decisions about their future. They need information, expertise, relationships, and the willingness to act.

Brad King is a board member of the Muncie Land Bank with experience in historic preservation, community advocacy, and urban planning.

www.munciepostdemocrat.com
Scroll to Top