Matt Wagley: 'I Won’t Be Used as a Political Tool’

11.20.2026 / News / Daisy Dale

MUNCIE, Ind. — When Muncie City Council held a public hearing Monday, November 16, over an investigation into the City Controller’s Office, Controller Matt Wagley accused council of attempting to make the Mayor’s Office “look bad” and were acting out of political motivation.

Wagley also claimed council members made previous-Controller Craig Wright’s life “miserable.” Wright died in August of this year, after the investigation was initiated in June. Wagley, in response to the set of questions submitted to him, told council at the podium: “You can try to exhume his [Wright’s] body if you want to but I can’t answer for him.”

The investigation itself follows a recent State Board Of Accounts report on the Muncie Parks Department that revealed a total of $21,471.10 was taken by former city employees George Foley and Nikki Eckerson. The news led council to authorize their own investigation into city financial operations and internal controls by a 8-1 vote.

Members of council have claimed that neither Wagley nor Wright over the summer have provided sufficient information since the investigation, and Wagley repeatedly told council on Monday that he did not have answers to most of the questions. The public hearing lasted nearly four hours, with 29 pages worth of questions directed at Wagley.

Council asked about various discrepancies, including $2.64 million in excess reported in 2021 and $3.55 million in 2022. Councilperson Nora Powell said it was a “fact-finding mission” rather than alleging criminal activity as Wagley claimed. 

Matt Wagley passing out previous audits from the State Board Of Accounts, claiming all the answers he doesn’t have are in the dockets.

Daisy Dale is the editor and publisher of The Muncie Post-Democrat, a commissioner for the Muncie Human Rights Commission, and a board member of Muncie Queer Alliance.

Scroll to Top